Home > IRA Questions, please

IRA Questions, please

February 1st, 2012 at 04:43 pm

May I have your thoughts on this question, please?

If I am currently in the 15% tax bracket and doubt that I will ever be above that.

About six years until retirement at age 60.

My question:

What advantage would a ROTH IRA be over just saving the same money in a regular taxable saving account considering I will never be in a different tax bracket?

Just wondering what other's thoughts on this would be.

5 Responses to “IRA Questions, please”

  1. creditcardfree Says:

    My first thought about those who might inherit your IRA. If it is a traditional IRA, they will be taxed at their earned income rate (which could be higher than yours), but if it is a ROTH it is tax free to all involved.

    And if just for your use, it really comes down to when you want to pay the taxes, now or later? Later you'll be paying 15% on earnings and contributions...not just contributions as you would with a Roth.

  2. BuckyBadger Says:

    Well, in a ROTH, you put in money that has already been taxed, and you are never ever taxed on any money that you make in interest. Ever.

    If you put that money in a taxable investment, you will be taxed every year on whatever money you make in that account.

    So a ROTH is better! It's such a powerful way to save money that they put some low limits on how much you can invest each year.

  3. MonkeyMama Says:

    As others mentioned, the earnings are tax-free.

    If you were asking about regular IRA versus ROTH, and were single, I'd probably advise the regular IRA considering your circumstances.

    But you are asking about ROTH versus taxable account. There is just no comparison.

    CCfree also mentions your heirs. In addition, since you are married, if one of you becomes widowed or divorced, your taxes could go up significantly. There is a HUGE "single penalty" in the tax code these days. You need less than $35k taxable income as a single to stay in 15% tax bracket, and would lose half your deductions (exemption, standard deduction). So the ROTH is generally better for you, your spouse and your heirs.

  4. retire@50 Says:

    Aside from the above there is no way to know how the tax rates will change in the future. Who knows they may do away with all deductions and have everyone pay 25% on investments. With a ROTH you won't have to worry about increases in tax rates.

  5. Mary Ann Says:

    Thanks everyone for your input!! You all are such a great help.

Leave a Reply

(Note: If you were logged in, we could automatically fill in these fields for you.)
Will not be published.

* Please spell out the number 4.  [ Why? ]

vB Code: You can use these tags: [b] [i] [u] [url] [email]